Compare DSL vs Cable Q & A

compare dsl vs cableDSL and cable broadband providers have been competing in many markets for so long that a certain rivalry and more than a little mudslinging has taken place as a result.  After all, there is little more that Americans like than a good old fashioned rivalry, and the entire desire to compare DSL vs cable broadband certainly stems from this innate need to challenge ourselves and our providers.  The problem is that not everyone even understands the fundamentals enough to compare DSL vs. cable broadband in an intelligent fashion.  To that end, we have compiled a list of common questions and answers in regards to the two rivals that should help you make some better informed choices in the entire compare DSL vs cable debate.

Question #1: Who is the Fastest in the DSL vs Cable Broadband Debate

Answer #1: Speed is a very relative thing, and there is no clear answer to this that holds true for every market and every usage pattern.  The only clear winner that can be declared here is the consumer, and this is because these two broadband technologies have pushed one another so far in such a short period of time that we are all winning every time a new network or network segment is deployed or upgraded regardless of DSL vs cable ownership.

Question #2: Who is the Cheapest in the DSL vs Cable Broadband Debate

Answer #2: Just as it is impossible to pick a speed winner in this debate, we are also hard pressed to declare a winner in terms of price other than to declare the average consumer the winner.  Simply put, the country has too many markets, need types, and usage patterns to really declare an overall winner in the debate between these two types of broadband.  They say that competition is good, and this only goes to prove that theory correct in hundreds of markets from sea to shining sea.

Question #3: What Are the Strengths of DSL?

Answer #3: DSL is widely available, fast, and even comes in different flavors that meet very different sets of needs in addition to the different speed grades.  Synchronous DSL, or SDSL for short, is often just what the performance doctor ordered for hosting and upload-intensive applications.  The wide availability of telecom-back DSL offerings from coast to coast easily make it one of the premier choices for broadband and a clear rival to cable modems.

Question #4: What Are the Strengths of Cable Broadband?

Answer #4: Like DSL, cable broadband is very fast.  There are not so many synchronous options in the realm of cable broadband, but there are often very impressive burst speeds that may make up for that seeming deficiency in the eyes of those with specific needs that could benefit from that type of performance.  The wide availability of cable broadband makes it a very popular choice, and a clear rival to DSL.

Question #5: Can You Compare DSL vs. Cable Modems?

Answer #5: Certainly, though few are interchangeable unless they support DSL and cable modem technologies.  That being said, when shopping for any type of broadband modem you want to be sure to get all of the specifications that you want and need within a single device.  This means the correct number and speed of local area Ethernet networking ports, the right WiFi standards, as well as other add-ons that you might want such as USB support for printers or storage, or even specific software functionality such as port forwarding or a firewall.

Question #6: How Can We Compare DSL vs Cable Futures?

Answer #6: Predicting the future of technology is like being able to predict the weather or the stock market.  You might be able to see a little bit in the future with some degree of clarity, but that clarity fades significantly with the distance over time with which you look.  Technology in general is known to be exceptionally difficult to accurately predict over great lengths of time.  That being said, it would seem that whole-home and office integration, cloud compatibility, and bonded lines doubling up on performance are likely to be the future of both technologies as they struggle to combat collective rivals such as fiber optics and electric company powered broadband.